Top 3 Flymphs or spiders?

[Mataura mayfly]

1: Purple & Starling (either with or without a bronze Peacock thorax)
2: Orange & partridge (or Mark Libertones Lil Dorothy)
3: Soft hackled Pogo Nymph.

[chase creek]

1. Gotta go with REE - Baillie's Black spider
2. March Brown Flymph
3. Partridge and Orange
Plus most any with Hare's Ear

[zen leecher]

My top two are:

Partridge and Orange
REE's Madison Cabbage
and I haven't really settled on a third as the above two are the ones I've had the best results with. Everything else is in "the noise".

[Premerger]

1. Brown grouse #14
2. March Brown spider #14
3. Stewart's spider #16.

[Smuggler]

I knew this would turn into a great thread.

[novabass]

My top two are:

Partridge and Orange
REE's Madison Cabbage
and I haven't really settled on a third as the above two are the ones I've had the best results with. Everything else is in "the noise".

What does REE's Madison Cabbage look like?

I knew this would turn into a great thread.

Yes, I'm really enjoying it! Great stuff all!

[daringduffer]

Hare's Lug and Partridge (yellow silk)
Black Spider
Endrick Spider

[Ruard]

Here are mine:

Holospider
Partridge and orange
Harelug and plover

greeting


Ruard

[zen leecher]

My top two are:

Partridge and Orange
REE's Madison Cabbage
and I haven't really settled on a third as the above two are the ones I've had the best results with. Everything else is in "the noise".

What does REE's Madison Cabbage look like?

I knew this would turn into a great thread.

Yes, I'm really enjoying it! Great stuff all!

There were some pictures of the Madison Cabbage on the board but the posters pulled the pictures. It's a sparkley purple dubbing and starling hackle.

[tie2fish]

This is not exactly the same, as it uses black hen instead of starling, but it's reasonably close. FWIW, this pattern took the largest brown I caught on the Madison last year.

Madison Cabbage Flymph Style.jpg (96.54 KiB) Viewed 6351 times