FLYMPH FORUM

Sorry if this is comes across as a really basic question but I'm having a difficult time breaking off the stem with residual partridge hackle after wrapping it around the front of the hook a couple of times... Any suggestions?

Use a scissors or exacto knife.

Welcome Taylor16. I hope we can help you out.

I think what you mean is the hackle keeps breaking off when you try to wrap it before you get to tie it in? Otherwise do as narcodog suggests

Partridge hackle is notorious for breaking, especially if it is old. First, make sure you are not twisting it as you wrap. Second, check your hackle pliers, if you are using them to make sure they are not cutting the stem. Use a hand over hand movement if you need to. Keep constant pressure on the hackle but not too much. You only need a couple wraps so make sure you are not grabbing the stem too close to the tip. Using hackle pliers, try to grab as far down from the hackle tip as you can.

This is a start.

It would help to know:
The method you are using to tie in and wrap the hackle
What are using to wrap the hackle

It's not so much that the stem breaks off but rather after I have ties two turns of hackle, I don't know how to exactly break the stem off without dragging or disrupting the hackle that was already in place. I have tried to cut is but I have seen some youtube videos where the tier just simply pulls and the stem breaks off neatly.

I have seen folks do that. It takes a snap. I have been tying for thirty years and I'll stick with the exacto or scissors. Exacto will get right down to your tye off and not hurt your hackle. that's just me. I'm not a power tyer so If it takes a few seconds to pick up the tool it makes no difference to me.

Yeah, snapping off the hackle takes a bit of practice. It's a "feel for it" thing. Most important thing is to make sure you are tying as tight as the thread will allow, then you need to give a quick snap against the tie down wraps. It's a bit easier with thinner thread and also helps if you give a twist to the thread so it is roped and not flat. I use it quite a bit but not all the time. Just depends on how feel.

Just tied a couple dozen north country-style soft hackles and I was starting to get the hang of it, I think... I know that the flies don't have to look "textbook" perfect but I'd still like to tie one where I didn't have at least one hackle fiber ahead of the eye! I guess I care more about how they look than the trout. They look fishy, nonetheless...

You're right - the fish don't really care. If it looks buggy, they'll eat it. I often think we tie more for ourselves than the fish.

taylor16 wrote:Just tied a couple dozen north country-style soft hackles and I was starting to get the hang of it, I think... I know that the flies don't have to look "textbook" perfect but I'd still like to tie one where I didn't have at least one hackle fiber ahead of the eye! I guess I care more about how they look than the trout. They look fishy, nonetheless...

Yep, "textbook" perfect is great for display flies- not that important for fishing flies. Sounds like you have found the balance.

In regard to snapping off hackle, you have had some pretty good advice above, just remember those that are good enough to make instructional videos -usually have an hour or two (decade or two more like) behind them in experience and have suffered through the same learning curve you are experiencing to get to where they are. Practise- practise and then practise some more......... and post some photos of your flies both just off the vice and in use.
Welcome aboard.

taylor16, Howdy;

Welcome to the forum.
I used to think it would be neat to snap things off while tying.
until I pulled the whole vise into my lap . I'm stickin' to
a sharp edge or a pair of sissors. My preferance, of course,
yours may differ. When I first started 3 years ago, my learning
curve was like a brick wall in front of me now it has some slope.
Great folks here to answer danged near any question you might have.
I haven't been able to stump them yet, and I've really been tryin'.
Where do you do your fishin' ? Warn water or cold water ?

hank